I get this call more often than people might expect. Someone’s been hit by a driver the police suspected was drunk, but the criminal case either stalled out, got pleaded down to something lesser, or never resulted in a conviction at all. The client assumes that’s the end of the road for any compensation. It isn’t, and I want to walk through why.
Can You Sue a Drunk Driver If They Weren’t Convicted of DWI in Arlington?
Yes. A criminal conviction is not required to bring a civil injury claim against a drunk driver in Arlington or anywhere else in Texas, and a criminal acquittal or dismissal does not bar one either. These are two separate legal systems with different purposes, different burdens of proof, and different outcomes. The criminal case exists to punish the driver on behalf of the state. The civil case exists to compensate you for what you lost. One can fail while the other succeeds, and that happens more than most people realize.
Why the Two Cases Run on Different Tracks?
Criminal DWI cases require proof beyond a reasonable doubt, which is the highest standard in our legal system. Prosecutors sometimes lose on a technicality, a breathalyzer calibration dispute, a blood draw that got challenged, or a plea deal that reduces the charge to something like reckless driving. None of that changes what happened on the road.
A civil claim for negligence only requires a preponderance of the evidence, meaning it’s more likely than not that the driver was impaired and that impairment caused the wreck. That’s a much lower bar. I’ve handled cases where the criminal charge got dismissed on a procedural issue, but we still had police bodycam footage, field sobriety test results, witness statements, and the officer’s own report describing slurred speech and the odor of alcohol. That’s often more than enough to build a strong civil case, even without a conviction sitting on the driver’s record.
What Evidence Actually Matters in the Civil Case?
In my experience, clients focus too much on whether charges were filed and not enough on preserving evidence early. The police report still matters even without a conviction attached to it. Officer observations noted at the scene, such as bloodshot eyes, unsteady balance, or admissions the driver made, carry weight in a civil case regardless of what happened in criminal court. Toxicology results, if they exist, are usable too. So are witness accounts from people who saw the driver before the crash, maybe leaving a bar or driving erratically beforehand.
One judgment call I make early in these cases is deciding whether to send a spoliation letter to preserve surveillance footage from a nearby business or traffic camera before it gets overwritten. That’s often a 30-to-60-day window, and if nobody asks for it in time, it’s gone. I’ve seen cases get meaningfully stronger just because someone pulled parking lot footage before it cycled out of storage.
A Scenario I See Often
A driver leaves a restaurant on Cooper Street or a bar near the entertainment district, runs a red light, and hits another car. Police arrive, smell alcohol, but the driver refuses field sobriety tests or the arresting officer’s report has a gap that a defense attorney later exploits. Charges get dropped. The injured driver assumes there’s nothing left to do.
That’s wrong. We still pursue the at-fault driver civilly for medical bills actually paid or incurred, lost wages, and pain and suffering. Texas law lets an injured person recover for those losses based on the preponderance standard, separate from whatever happened in the criminal courtroom. You don’t need the state to win its case for you to win yours.
Texas Proportionate Responsibility and What It Means Here
Texas follows a proportionate responsibility rule under Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code 33.001. If you’re found more than 50 percent responsible for the crash, you can’t recover damages. If your share of fault is 50 percent or less, your recovery gets reduced by your percentage of responsibility under Section 33.012. In a drunk driving case, this usually works in the injured person’s favor, since evidence of the other driver’s impairment tends to shift responsibility heavily toward them. But insurance companies still argue comparative fault aggressively, so this needs to be addressed directly, not assumed away.
Punitive Damages Without a Conviction
Clients sometimes ask whether punitive damages require a criminal conviction too. They don’t. Exemplary damages in Texas are generally capped under Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code 41.008(b) at the greater of $200,000, or two times economic damages plus noneconomic damages up to $750,000. However, Section 41.008(c) removes that cap for conduct described as a felony in sections it lists, which includes intoxication assault under Penal Code 49.07 and intoxication manslaughter under Penal Code 49.08. Whether that exception applies depends on the conduct itself, not on whether the driver was actually convicted of that felony. Either way, exemplary damages require clear and convincing evidence of fraud, malice, or gross negligence, decided by a unanimous jury. Intoxication by itself doesn’t automatically produce them.
Other Angles Worth Considering
Depending on the facts, there may be a separate claim against the bar, restaurant, or business that served the driver. Under Tex. Alco. Bev. Code 2.02(b), a provider can be liable if it was apparent at the time of service that the person was obviously intoxicated to the point of presenting a clear danger to themselves or others, and that intoxication proximately caused the damages. This is a fact-specific inquiry, not something tied to a drink count or a BAC number, and it’s a claim we evaluate case by case.
For a broader look at how these cases get built from the ground up, our Texas DWI Accident Attorney page covers the general process, and our Arlington-specific guide covers practical steps for victims right after a crash.
The Filing Deadline Still Applies
Regardless of what happens criminally, Texas generally gives you two years from the date of the crash to file a personal injury lawsuit under Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code 16.003. Waiting on a criminal case to resolve before deciding whether to pursue a civil claim can eat into that window. I’ve had people wait over a year for a plea deal, only to realize they now have a fraction of the time left to build a civil case properly.
What I’d Tell Someone Facing This Right Now?
If you were hit by a driver you believe was impaired and the criminal case didn’t go anywhere, don’t treat that as the final answer. The standards are different, the evidence that matters is different, and in many cases, a dismissal or acquittal in criminal court has little bearing on what a civil jury would decide. For more background on general resources around DWI law, the American Bar Association and Justia Legal Information both maintain useful public explanations of how civil and criminal liability diverge.
I’ve built my practice around these exact situations, and our about our practice page covers how our team approaches case evaluation from day one. You can also read client reviews to see how past cases were resolved.
If you’re in Arlington and dealing with this right now, reach out. Visit our Arlington office at 4275 Little Rd # 205, Arlington, TX 76016, or call us directly at (817) 203-8018. Dashner Law Firm | Arlington Injury & Accident Attorney serves clients throughout Arlington and across Texas, and we’re glad to look at what happened in your case and tell you honestly where things stand. You can also contact us online anytime to get started.