Most people who call our office after a wreck on 183 or North MacArthur Boulevard want to know one thing first: who’s going to pay for this. The honest answer in Texas depends on a legal rule most drivers have never heard of until they need it. I’ve spent years walking Irving clients through how fault actually gets divided after a crash, and it surprises almost everyone the first time I explain it. This post covers that rule in plain terms, plus the questions I hear most often from people dealing with it in real time.
If you’re trying to sort out a claim right now, Dashner Law Firm | Irving Injury & Accident Attorney works with clients throughout Irving and the wider Dallas-Fort Worth area on exactly this kind of dispute, and we serve clients across Texas more broadly.
What Does It Mean That Texas Uses Proportionate Responsibility For Car Accidents In Irving?
Proportionate responsibility is the legal framework Texas uses to decide how much, if anything, an injured person can recover when more than one party contributed to a crash. Under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 33.001, a claimant cannot recover any damages if their own share of fault is found to be greater than 50 percent. If a jury or insurance adjuster finds you 50 percent or less responsible, you can still recover — but your total damages get reduced by your own percentage of fault under Section 33.012. So if you suffered $100,000 in damages and you’re found 20 percent responsible, you’d recover $80,000 of actual losses, subject to the limits described below. This is sometimes called modified comparative fault, and it applies to essentially every car accident claim handled in Irving and the rest of Texas.
What trips people up is the word “proportionate.” It doesn’t mean fault gets split 50/50 by default. It means a specific percentage gets assigned to each party involved, based on the facts, and that percentage directly controls the outcome. A police report, photos, witness statements, and the vehicle damage pattern all feed into that percentage. Insurance companies know this system well and use it aggressively — which is one reason the percentage they assign you in their internal file often looks worse than what actually happened.
How Do Insurance Adjusters Decide Who Was More At Fault After An Irving Crash?
In my experience, this is the part clients misunderstand most. There’s no neutral referee assigning fault percentages after a wreck. Each insurance company has its own adjuster, and that adjuster’s job is to protect their employer’s money — not to find the truth for you. The percentage they assign you isn’t a court ruling. It’s an internal number their company uses to calculate what they’re willing to pay, and it’s often a starting point for negotiation rather than a final word.
Adjusters typically build their fault assessment from the police crash report, statements taken from both drivers shortly after the accident, photos of vehicle damage and the scene, and sometimes traffic camera footage if it exists. A citation issued at the scene carries weight in that assessment, but a ticket does not决定 civil liability on its own — it’s one piece of evidence among several, not an automatic finding of fault.
One pattern I’ve seen repeatedly working crashes along Story Road and near the 635/183 interchange: a driver who was only slightly careless gets assigned 40 or 50 percent fault by the other side’s insurer, simply because no one pushed back with better evidence. Dashcam footage, a second witness, or even the geometry of the damage can shift that percentage substantially. I’ve had cases where an initial adjuster assessment of 50 percent fault dropped to 15 percent once we presented additional documentation. That’s not a guaranteed outcome for every case, but it illustrates why the first number an insurer gives you shouldn’t be treated as the final answer.
Can Something Like Not Wearing A Seat Belt Be Used Against Me In Irving?
Yes. Texas courts allow evidence of seat belt nonuse to be considered when a jury apportions responsibility. The Texas Supreme Court addressed this directly in Nabors Well Services, Ltd. v. Romero, 456 S.W.3d 553 (Tex. 2015), which overruled the older rule that kept this evidence out. If you weren’t wearing a seat belt at the time of a crash in Irving, and the other side can show that contributed to the severity of your injuries, that fact can be factored into your assigned percentage of fault — even if you had nothing to do with causing the collision itself.
This matters because it’s a detail people don’t think to mention to their own attorney, assuming it’s irrelevant since “the other driver ran the light.” It isn’t irrelevant. It’s a separate question from who caused the crash. One is about fault for the collision; the other is about whether your own conduct made your injuries worse. Both get weighed in the same proportionate responsibility calculation. I bring this up early with every client because the other side’s insurer or defense counsel will bring it up eventually, and it’s better to address it head-on than have it surface as a surprise.
Does It Matter What Kind Of Crash I Was In — Like A Rear-End Or Left-Turn Accident?
It matters for building the factual argument, but no collision type decides fault automatically under Texas law. I hear this misconception constantly: “I got rear-ended, so it’s not even my fault — that’s just the law.” It isn’t quite that simple. A rear-end collision, a left-turn crash, or a lane-change accident each creates a strong practical argument for the following or turning driver’s responsibility, because of how traffic laws and common sense usually apply to those situations. But “strong argument” is different from “automatic conclusion.” The specific facts — following distance, visibility, whether brake lights were working, whether the lead driver stopped suddenly without cause — still get examined.
I’ve worked rear-end cases out of the service roads near the DFW Connector where the driver who got hit still ended up with some assigned percentage of fault, because evidence showed a sudden, unnecessary stop. It’s not common, but it happens enough that I never tell a client their case is a sure thing based solely on the type of collision. Treating any crash type as an automatic win is exactly the kind of assumption that leads to a weaker negotiating position later.
What Should I Do Right After A Crash In Irving To Protect My Percentage Of Fault?
This is where your actions in the first hours and days genuinely shape the number an insurer eventually assigns you. Under Texas Transportation Code Section 550.026, if a crash results in injury, death, or vehicle damage severe enough that a car can’t be driven safely, the driver must report it immediately, by the quickest means available, to local police or the sheriff’s department. That’s not optional and it has no dollar threshold attached to it — contrary to what a lot of people assume.
Separately, if an officer responds and investigates, that officer has their own duty under Section 550.062 to file a written report with TxDOT within 10 days, but only when the crash involved injury, death, or apparent property damage of $1,000 or more. That 10-day window belongs to the investigating officer, not to you as a driver — you’re not the one filing that report, and there’s no old CR-2 “blue form” to worry about either, since Texas eliminated that driver-filed form back in September 2017.
Beyond the reporting obligation, here’s what I tell every Irving client: get the other driver’s insurance information and plate number, photograph both vehicles from multiple angles before anything gets moved if it’s safe to do so, and get contact information for anyone who saw what happened. Then see a doctor, even if you feel okay. Gaps between the crash date and your first medical visit are one of the most common things insurance adjusters point to when arguing that your injuries weren’t caused by the wreck, or weren’t as serious as claimed. None of this guarantees a specific fault percentage, but weak documentation almost always works against you, never for you.
How Texas Insurance Minimums Affect What You Can Actually Collect?
Fault percentage is only half the picture. The other half is whether there’s enough insurance money available to cover what you’re owed after that percentage gets applied. Texas law requires drivers to carry at least $30,000 per injured person and $60,000 per crash in bodily injury liability coverage, plus $25,000 in property damage coverage — commonly written as 30/60/25, under Texas Transportation Code Section 601.072. Those numbers are the legal floor, not a description of what any particular claim is worth, and they cap what the at-fault driver’s own policy will pay regardless of how severe the injuries are.
This is why uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage matters so much in a market like Irving, where I-635, State Highway 183, and the Airport Freeway corridor see a steady mix of commuter and commercial traffic. Texas doesn’t require UM/UIM coverage — insurers are required to offer it, and a driver has to reject it in writing if they don’t want it, under Texas Insurance Code Section 1952.101. A lot of people don’t realize they declined it until after a crash with a driver who’s underinsured, at which point it’s too late to add. If your own fault percentage comes in low but the at-fault driver only carries the state minimum, UM/UIM coverage on your own policy can be the only path to recovering losses beyond what their policy will pay.
Medical expense recovery also has a specific rule worth knowing: Texas law limits recovery to the amount actually paid or incurred for treatment, not the full amount originally billed, under Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 41.0105. That distinction matters a lot once insurance write-downs and billed charges enter the picture, and it’s a detail general crash guides tend to skip over entirely.
Why This Rule Makes Early Legal Guidance Worth Getting?
Proportionate responsibility means every fact gathered in the days after your crash can move your percentage up or down, and that percentage directly determines your recovery. I’ve sat across from clients who assumed their case was simple, only to find the insurer had quietly built a file assigning them 35 or 40 percent fault based on one ambiguous witness statement. Correcting that after the fact is harder than getting it right from the start.
Our firm has handled proportionate responsibility disputes for clients throughout Irving, Dallas, Grand Prairie, and the surrounding North Texas communities, and you can read what past clients have said about that work in our client reviews. You can also learn more about our team and the broader scope of our Texas practice, which includes Texas Truck Accident Attorneys, Texas Motorcycle Accident Attorneys, and Texas Pedestrian Accident Attorneys work, alongside our core Texas Car Accident Attorneys practice. For general background on how civil liability works in the U.S., Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute and Justia both maintain accessible overviews of comparative fault systems nationally, and the American Bar Association offers consumer-facing guidance on working with an attorney after an accident.
If you were hurt in a crash anywhere in Irving and you’re not sure how the insurance company arrived at the percentage they’re quoting you, don’t just accept it. Dashner Law Firm | Irving Injury & Accident Attorney can review the facts, the report, and the insurer’s reasoning, and tell you honestly whether that number holds up. There’s no upfront cost to have that conversation, and we’re only paid from a recovery if we win your case. Call (972) 635-4460 or contact us to set up a consultation. Our Irving office is located at 4500 Fuller Dr, Irving, TX 75038, and you’re welcome to visit us in Irving or reach out online to get started.
Written by Geoffrey Dashner.